What would change?
With a refinance, the existing mortgage is paid off and replaced. The new loan can change the balance, rate, term, payment, and closing costs.
Homeowners may have ways to access equity without replacing their current mortgage, taking on a cash-out refinance, or adding a traditional monthly loan payment. This page explains the main options and what to consider before moving forward.
Published August 15, 2026 • Last reviewed September 9, 2026
A cash-out refinance changes the entire first mortgage. If the current loan has features a homeowner wants to keep—such as its rate, payment, remaining term, or predictable structure—it can make sense to compare equity options that do not replace that loan.
With a refinance, the existing mortgage is paid off and replaced. The new loan can change the balance, rate, term, payment, and closing costs.
A HELOC, home equity loan, or some home equity contracts may sit alongside the first mortgage instead of replacing it. That preserves the first loan but creates a separate obligation.
The right comparison depends on whether the homeowner needs one lump sum or repeated access, can accept a monthly payment, and expects to sell or refinance in the foreseeable future.
The first mortgage can remain in place while a homeowner considers another equity-based structure. The tradeoffs are not interchangeable.
A revolving line of credit secured by home equity. A HELOC generally has a draw period, minimum payments, and usually a variable interest rate. Payments can change as the balance and rate change.
Better suited to: homeowners who value repeated borrowing flexibility and can manage a credit-line payment.
A separate loan secured by the home, commonly funded as a lump sum and repaid through scheduled monthly payments. If a first mortgage already exists, this is typically an additional mortgage obligation.
Better suited to: homeowners who want a defined lump sum and a traditional repayment schedule.
A company provides cash upfront and the homeowner later owes a lump-sum settlement based in part on the home’s value and the contract terms. Many contracts do not require recurring principal-and-interest payments.
Key tradeoff: avoiding a traditional monthly payment does not eliminate cost or the future settlement obligation.
Review what must be paid at sale and how the payoff is calculated. A home equity contract may require settlement when the home is sold.
Ask whether the new equity obligation must be paid off, subordinated, or otherwise addressed before another mortgage can close.
Pay attention to the maximum term, any caps or formulas, and how home appreciation could affect a future settlement amount.
Possibly. A HELOC, home equity loan, or home equity contract may use home equity without replacing the existing first mortgage. Each option has different qualification, payment, lien, cost, and settlement requirements.
No. A second mortgage or HELOC adds a new debt obligation, and a home equity contract can create a future lump-sum settlement obligation tied in part to the home’s value. The documents should be reviewed carefully.
A cash-out refinance replaces the existing mortgage. A homeowner may prefer to preserve the current loan if its rate, payment, remaining term, or other features are attractive, while still comparing other ways to use equity.
No. Home equity contracts, often marketed as HEIs or home equity agreements, are generally structured differently from a traditional home equity loan. They commonly involve an upfront payment and a future lump-sum settlement based in part on the home’s value.
BP Housing reviews the information you provide and contacts you to discuss your goals and possible next steps. Independent providers determine their own eligibility, pricing, terms, and approval decisions.
The CFPB explains that a mortgage refinance replaces the old mortgage with a new loan, while HELOCs and home equity loans use home equity without necessarily replacing the first mortgage. The CFPB also describes home equity contracts as agreements involving upfront cash and a later lump-sum settlement based in part on the home’s value.
External government resources are provided for education. BP Housing is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CFPB.Choose the next guide based on the question you are actually trying to answer.
Compare a revolving line of credit with other structures.
Understand the contract structure before comparing it with loans.
Learn what can drive the future lump-sum obligation.
BP Housing is not a lender and does not make credit decisions. Home equity options, eligibility, funding amounts, and terms are determined by independent providers. Information on this page is for general educational purposes and should not be considered financial, legal, or tax advice.
The guide above is general education. If you want BP Housing to review the information you choose to provide about your property and goals, the inquiry form is available separately.
Go to the Home Equity Review form →